I will use the following twobytwo table for subsequent developments. In epidemiological terms, the odds ratio is used as a point estimate of the relative risk in retrospective studies. The relative risk rr and the odds ratio or are the two most widely used measures of association in epidemiology. Relationships among three popular measures of differential. Epidemiologists use sex ratio and dependency ratio. Some studies use relative risks rrs to describe results. If its above 1, then the tutored group actually had a higher risk of failing than the controls.
Understanding odds ratios, absolute risk reduction, relative risk, and nnt duration. The relative risk is easier to interpret, so the odds ratio alone is not very helpful. Relative risks and odds ratios statistics 149 spring 2006. Odds ratio and attributable risk retrospective statsdirect. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The relative risk, risk difference, and odds ratio are the three most commonly used measures for comparing the risk of disease between different groups. If that is not the case the fundamental differences between these measures will be more and more noticable. T o use or not to use the odds ratio in epidemiologic studies. Terry shaneyfelt, md, mph associate professor of medicine uab school of medicine 2. An odds ratio the ratio of the relative odds of the disease occurring in group a. The difference between odds and probability is important because relative risk is calculated with probability and odds ratio is calculated with odds. Relative risk rr is a ratio of probabilities or put another way it is one probability divided by another. The odds ratio is the ratio of the odds of an event in the treatment group to the odds of an event in the control group. This suggests that for a prospective cluster randomised trial the relative risk is easier to interpret.
Relative risk, odds ratio, attributable risk and number needed to treat an improved version of this article is now available in third edition 2012 of the book medical biostatistics crc press, new york by abhaya indrayan adapted from basic methods of medical research, third edition. Convert hazards ratio to odds ratio cross validated. Converting the odds ratio to the relative risk in cohort. Moreover, study 3 would have shown the smallest relative risk a 15%. Obviously, these results run counter to expected results, putting the onus on the researcher to justify them. Dit artikel gaat over het gebruik van oddsratios en risico ratios zie uitlegkader. Over 10 million scientific documents at your fingertips. Odds ratio or or is the ratio between odds of exposed group and unexposed group.
Relative risk regression can be implemented quite easily with most standard software packages. Relative risk and odds ratio in epidemiology the relative risk rr and the odds ratio or are the two most widely used measures of association in epidemiology. These two measures are the odds ratio and relative risk. What is the difference between odds ratio and relative risk. The relative risk or risk ratio is an intuitive way to compare the risks for the two groups. Risk of the outcome in the exposed group was reduced by 20% or occurred 20% less relative to the unexposed group. Examples calculating relative risk calculating relative risk imagine that the incidence of gun violence is compared in two cities, one with relaxed gun laws a, the other with strict gun laws b. Odds and risk are the most common terms which are used as measures of association between variables.
The relative risk rr or risk ratio is the ratio of the probability of an outcome in an exposed group to the probability of an outcome in an unexposed group. For the study examining wound infections after incidental appendectomy, the risk of wound infection in each exposure group is estimated from the cumulative incidence. In this article, which is the fourth in the series of common pitfalls in statistical analysis, we explain the meaning of risk and odds and the difference between the two. Relative risk and odds ratio the relative risk rr is the probability that a member of an exposed group will develop a disease relative to the probability that a member of an unexposed group will develop that same disease. Or and rr are used to measure the relationship between disease status disease present vs. The relative risk is best estimated using a population sample, but if the rare disease assumption holds, the odds ratio is a good approximation to the relative risk the odds is p 1. Many research papers present findings as odds ratios ors and relative risks rrs as measures of effect size for categorical outcomes.
The appropriate use of these statistics to estimate the. What is the difference between the risk ratio rr, and. Comparing proportions with relative risk and odds ratios. Interpreting odds ratio with two independent variables in binary logistic. Odds ratio, hazard ratio and relative risk 67 8 nurminen, m. This procedure will compile a 2x2 table from the data and calculate the relative risk and odds ratio for the observed data. Risk or probability is more intuitive, and in the same way relative risk seems to. The direct computation of relative risks is feasible if meaningful prevalences.
Since odds are not intuitive, the odds ratio will also not be intuitive. The odds ratio acbd looks at the likelihood of an outcome in relation to a characteristic factor. Feb 25, 2016 note that the relative risk is also called the risk ratio in the literature, but for convenience we use the term relative risk hereafter. By using the study sample data thus tabulated, investigators quantify the association between treatment or risk factor and outcome. James pans answer is accurate and helpful in answering the question, but i would add some additional important characteristics 1. If the relative risk is 1, the tutoring made no difference at all. Relative risk is usually defined as the ratio of two success proportions. The use of odds ratio in the large populationbased studies.
The risk factor was associated with increased odds of being diagnosed. Feb 24, 20 odds ratio an odds ratio is the odds of the event in one group, for example, those exposed to a drug, divided by the odds of the event in another group not exposed odd ratio in epidemiology. When two groups are under study or observation, you can use two measures to describe the comparative likelihood of an event happening. Three simple statistical calculations are used for this purpose.
Relative risk in epidemiology, relative risk rr can give us insights in how much more likely an exposed group is to develop a certain disease in comparison to a nonexposed group. To investigate this we turn to relative risk and odds ratios. Since the relative risk is a simple ratio, errors tend to occur when the terms more or less are used. Once we know the exposure and disease status of a research population, we can fill in. When the data to be analyzed consist of counts in a crossclassification of two groups or conditions and two outcomes, the data can be represented in a fourfold table as follows. We can compare two sets of odds with an odds ratio or and we can compare two sets of risks or probabilities with the relative risk rr. What is the difference between the risk ratio rr, and the. Odds ratio and relative risk question 1 the following is the abstract of a paper illi et al. Apr 24, 2017 james pans answer is accurate and helpful in answering the question, but i would add some additional important characteristics 1.
The odds ratio is the only parameter that can be used to compare two groups of binary responses from retrospective studies. Estimating the relative risk in cohort studies and. What is the difference between odds ratio and risk ratio. Early presentations of the casecontrol approach were often presented in this context,7 and it was emphasized that the odds ratio was approximately equal to the risk ratio when the disease was rare.
It is no less valid as a mathematical expression than the risk ratio, but its less intuitive nature leads many investigators to prefer to talk about the risk ratio, a. Since relative risk is a more intuitive measure of effectiveness, the distinction is important especially in cases of medium to high probabilities. A most odd ratio interpreting and describing odds ratios. What does the odds ratio estimate in a casecontrol study. The odds ratio relative odds is a good approximation of the relative risk when the following conditions are met select all that apply. Together with risk difference and odds ratio, relative risk measures the association between the exposure and the outcome. The odds ratio or is the ratio of odds of an event in one group versus the odds of the event in the other group. Suppose you have a school that wants to test out a new tutoring program. The other day i was emailing with a statistical genetics colleague about a rare snp associated with a phenotype. Odds ratio versus relative risk odds ratio can be calculated in a cohort study and in a casecontrol study. The odds ratio or is the odds of an event in an experimental group relative to that in a control group. The basic difference is that the odds ratio is a ratio of two odds yep, its that obvious whereas the relative risk is a ratio of two probabilities. Which one you decide to use is a matter of personal preference and perhaps your audience.
Converting odds ratio to relative risk in cohort studies with partial data information zhu wang ut health san antonio abstract in medical and epidemiological studies, the odds ratio is a. Most researchers apply this formula to the adjusted odds ratio to estimate an adjusted relative risk. Odds ratio, likelihood ratio, relative risk pvalue or lr rr lactose intolerance rs4988235 8e4 5. The relative risk rr compares the frequency of an outcome between groups and represents the ratio of the probability of the outcome. Although widely popular in biomedical and psychosocial research, the relationship among the three. Relative risk and odds ratio european public health. Using the formula in this manner is incorrect and will produce a biased estimate when confounding is present. Download pdf nederlands tijdschrift voor geneeskunde. Can you explain the difference between these two numbers. How strong is the association between exposure and outcome. How to convert odds ratios to relative risks rbloggers. In case control study since the incidence is not available so relative risk can not be calculated directly. Relative risk and odds ratios examples home the atrium. Or odds of exposed group a c odds of unexposed group b d table 1.
In all ratios, the two items under comparison are different entities, and none is part of the other. The relative risk rr is the risk of the event in an experimental group relative to that in a control group. We can calculate the relative risk in r by hand doing something like this. Its never wrong to use odds ratio or, but where you have the true incidence rate it is preferred that you use the. Rr pdiseasejexposed pdiseasejunexposed if an event takes place with probability p, the odds in favor of the event are p. Odds ratio an odds ratio is the odds of the event in one group, for example, those exposed to a drug, divided by the odds of the event in another group not exposed odd ratio in epidemiology. The interpretation of each is presented in plain english rather than in technical language. Case study relative risk and odds ratio john snows cholera investigations population information 2 water providers. Risk ratio or relative risk rr rr is the ratio between the risk of exposed group and unexposed group. Albuminglobulin ratio as a biochemical parameter and embolustoblood ratio for doppler are examples. Both are two different statistical concepts, although so much related to each other. A relative risk is much easier to interpret and makes much more sense to the layman e. The concept and method of calculation are explained for each of these in simple terms and with the help of examples. Proportions, risk ratios and odds ratios risk ratio or relative risk chisquared tests are tests of significance, they do not provide estimates of the strength of relationships.
Rr pdiseasejexposed pdiseasejunexposed if an event takes place with probability p, the odds in favor of the event. Risk ratios were calculated from hazard ratios based on cox regression coefficients derived. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has. Relative risks, odds ratios and cluster randomised trials. Probability is the likelihood of an event in relation to all possible events. The absolute risk is the probability of an event in a sample or population of interest. To investigate the association between early childhood infections and subsequent development of asthma. The difference between relative risk and odds ratios the. From this contingency table, we can calculate an odds ratio and likelihood ratio. However, there are certain commonly occurring situations in which the estimate of the relative risk is not very good and the odds ratio can be used to approximate the relative risk of the event of interest. The relative risk also known as risk ratio rr is the ratio of risk of an event in one group e. There are different ways of doing this for different kinds of data and sizes of table, but two are particularly important in health research.
Unfortunately, in some situations, you just have to get an or, notably logistic regression and retrospective casecontrol studies. The relative risk and the odds ratio are measures of association between exposure status and disease outcome in a population. Understanding relative risk, odds ratio, and related terms. You may have noticed that the odds ratio and relative risk are very similar in this case. Odds ratio versus relative risk created by 20010109 dear professor mean. It is computed as, where is the incidence in the exposed group, and is the incidence in the unexposed group. In a case control study, this is the ratio between the fraction with the risk variant versus nonrisk. However, it is less well appreciated that for a log link, the population parameters are the same and a log link leads to a relative risk. This work is licensed under a creative commons attribution. Obtain empirical sampling distributions of sample rr and or and observe coverage rate of 95% confidence. The question of which statistic to use is subtle but very important. Formula 2 can be utilized for both the unadjusted and. There is some confusion about the use of the odds ratio versus the relative risk.
Both the odds ratio and the relative risk compare the likelihood of an event between two groups. When the data to be analyzed consist of counts in a crossclassification of two groups or conditions and two outcomes, the data can be. The exposure odds ratio is equal to the disease odds ratio relative risk can only be calculated in a cohort study. Then the relative risk of having the illness in the study population relative to the reference population is simply the ratio of these. Ratio is the frequency of one item compared to another. The risk difference is an absolute measure of effect i. Jan 27, 2014 the homemade video abstract on the bmj website shows you the difference between odds and risk, and how one odds ratio can mean several different relative risks rrs, depending on the risk in one of the groups. From the definitions above, we immediately see that the three measures have quite different ranges. In the city with relaxed gun laws, there were 50 shootings in a. Proportions, odds, and risk1 adiology christopher l. Because it is a ratio and expresses how many times more probable the outcome is in the exposed group, the simplest solution is to incorporate the words times the risk or times as high as in your interpretation. This happens when the proportions being compared are both close to 0. Creative commons attributionnoncommercialsharealike license.
The odds ratio of the second population relative to the first is 1419 2. When the cases studied are representative, regarding the history of exposure, to all people with the disease in the population from which the cases were drawn. The relative risk also called the risk ratio or prevalence ratio or relative prevalence is. The homemade video abstract on the bmj website shows you the difference between odds and risk, and how one odds ratio can mean several different relative risks rrs, depending on the risk in one of the groups. It is important to understand this feature of the odds ratio because you will see it referred to as an approximation of the risk ratio. The comparison of odds extends nicely to regression analysis e. Often the quantity of interest although additive risk should also be considered. Relative risk ratios for static99r scores sexual recidivism static99r score frequency n risk ratio 3 73 0. Relative risk and odds ratios examples university of guelph atrium. Relative risk regression columbia university mailman school. Odds ratio is the key statistic for most casecontrol studies. For a given trial duration, particular distribution for event occurence and a particular dropout pattern, there is a correspondence of hazard ratio to odds ratio to relative risk ratio. University of york department of health sciences applied biostatistics exercise. Early presentations of the casecontrol approach were often presented in this context,7 and it was emphasized that the odds ratio was approximately equal to.
173 272 1474 1299 42 1386 416 446 509 485 414 375 308 169 386 1439 1492 1107 160 1140 3 174 786 394 1109 1183 1056 233 985 395 936 483 439 166 1437